If you happen to’re an anime fan, then you definately’re most likely effectively conscious of how dissatisfied individuals are with The Promised Neverland Season 2.
After an outstanding first season, the present garnered a large fanbase. New followers had been excited to see what got here subsequent in a narrative that masterfully twisted and rotated a easy premise. Followers of the supply materials, in the meantime, couldn’t wait to see how the remainder of the collection could be tailored, particularly for the reason that manga had accomplished its run earlier than the second season was even introduced.
It was a really perfect situation for a second season to come back into. And but, after just a few episodes, it grew to become clear that the present would possibly effectively squander all of this goodwill.
New followers discovered the story that drew them in with its considerate pacing rocketing towards a sudden and messy conclusion. In only a handful of episodes, they noticed the kids pace by means of their adolescence and monitor down the world’s massive unhealthy, with barely any point out manufactured from how they did so and the way they deliberate to avoid wasting the brand new world they entered.
Followers of the manga, in the meantime, found that the overwhelming majority of the supply materials could be omitted, with fan-favorite characters erased totally from the anime’s story. Specifically, The Goldie Pond arc , which is considered the manga’s greatest arc, was omitted totally.
This meant that key mentor characters like Yugo and Lucas, and the formidable villain Lewis, had been fully taken out of the collection in consequence. As such, the primary solid by no means acquired some essential moments of character growth that got here with them, and felt underdeveloped in consequence.
Issues didn’t get any higher by the top of the season. The ultimate arc it tried to adapt felt simply as rushed, with key occasions and moments from the finale even being proven by means of a slideshow as a substitute of precise animation.
Evidently, folks weren’t pleased with the ultimate product. One can discover loads of opinions about how disheartening the entire state of affairs has been, and the extra devoted fanbase of the collection has been left hoping it would someday get one other, extra story-faithful adaptation ala Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood.
There’s one upside to The Promised Neverland anime’s distinctive failure, although, and it comes within the type of a bolstered lesson for the trade as an entire: Anime studios shouldn’t rush to get an adaptation out, and will belief that their fanbases will probably be keen to attend for the most effective one potential.
It’s an idea that isn’t precisely overseas to anime as an trade. There have been loads of exhibits which had large, years-long breaks between the discharge of their seasons regardless of the huge recognition they loved. Most of the time, this didn’t deter followers within the slightest, with exhibits sustaining the recognition they’d upon their preliminary launch.
A number of the greatest examples embrace Durarara!! and Mushishi. Every noticed their second seasons launch effectively after their preliminary booms in recognition, however nonetheless managed to garner the identical appreciation from followers they might have had with an earlier launch.
And but, this technique is one thing that also isn’t as extensively embraced appropriately, particularly amongst shonen anime like The Promised Neverland. Reveals on this style have continuously seen seasons rushed out with the intention to capitalize on their recognition, glossing over supply materials or speeding to get no matter is on the market out as quickly as potential.
Most of the time, this solely causes the fanbases to get bored with the property. The the reason why can fluctuate. It could possibly be as a result of there’s not sufficient supply materials, resulting in filler arcs or excessively drawn-out storytelling. Or, it could possibly be because of the large drop in high quality that comes from the studio not taking the time to shine the present to the primary season’s requirements.
Regardless, the end result stays the identical: A promising anime adaptation loses all of its momentum, resulting in a subpar ending and a tarnished legacy.
That is precisely what occurred with The Promised Neverland. Instantly after the top of its first season, the second season was introduced to be in growth. It was then slated for launch through the Fall 2020 anime season, solely being delayed into 2021 because of the Coronavirus pandemic.
This gave Cloverworks solely a 12 months and a half to adapt the following a part of the collection, although the goodwill from the primary season may have afforded them one or two extra years to correctly hone it into one thing superb. Likewise, they may have feared they couldn’t retain their sizable fanbase over the course of a number of seasons, as a substitute opting to hurry out the complete story to seize as many quick viewers as potential.
In consequence, it grew to become the rushed and incomplete last product that followers now know and detest, and the collection’ recognition has been gutted irreparably.
Evidently, it’s a reasonably clear-cut cautionary story. And but, even with The Promised Neverland anime’s failure, there would usually be the prospect of studios not studying from it and repeating its errors.
Happily, this won’t be the case. In a stroke of luck, The Promised Neverland’s failure occurred throughout the identical season that one other anime continued to succeed regardless of taking years-long breaks between its many seasons. Not solely that, however it took its time adapting each arc, making certain nothing was omitted.
That present is none apart from Assault on Titan.
First airing in April of 2013, Assault on Titan grew to become infamous for taking intensive breaks from airing new episodes over its ongoing four-season run. Between its first and second season alone, there was a virtually four-year hole, leaving followers anxiously awaiting new content material.
Regardless of these lengthy breaks, it maintained its foothold as one of the crucial in style anime diversifications ever. Each arc from its supply materials has been tailored nearly to the letter, and the story has been paced in a manner that feels pure and simple to observe. In consequence, followers have returned for every new season, and it has remained a juggernaut all the best way as much as its now last story arc.
This has been excellent news not just for Assault on Titan, however for anime usually. There’s now indeniable and profitable proof that taking the time wanted to place out the most effective adaptation potential pays off, and that different collection may see extra success by choosing endurance over quick features.
In an ideal world, The Promised Neverland anime would have been the difference its supply materials deserved. It could have continued to be revered as probably the greatest anime in the marketplace, and will have served to attract in much more followers with every new arc from the manga it dropped at life.
This isn’t the case although, and as a substitute, followers must be pleased with a silver lining. The Promised Neverland could have failed, however with a bit of luck, this failure may function a warning for different anime studios to be taught from.